Which ''comment page" do you like best?

[Lollies]

Full Page - The one that comes up on the screen with a place to write your comment on the right and all existing comments on the left.
Pop Up Window - The small pop-up window with a list of existing comments and a place to write your own at the bottom.
Embedded Below Post - The white text box that appears below your post for people to write comments.

I'm curious to see what you all say.
I personally go for the Embedded Below Post or Full Page one. I don't like the pop up for a couple of reasons...
- If you include a link in your comment your blog comes up in a really small page which you has no toolbar and you have to resize it.
- You Have to scroll right to the bottom of all the comments in order to write one.

Which do you all like best?

[arles]

I like embedded and pop up. The whole other page isn't great because when I'm tying if I want to refrence anything in the post I hae to click off it to re-read the post.

My blog is embedded below post. I like it that way. I think to a certain degree people should keep thier blgos the way they like it.

[peebsmama]

I like the pop up best because when I'm done commenting, I can close that window and still be on the blog without having to go back. Sometimes with the embedded, I am not able to leave a comment. Not sure why, but it has been a problem. I don't like the full page for the same reason Arles stated.

[shellpole]

Love the embedded coz I can still see what I am commenting about!

Hate verification though...waste of time and truly very hard to read.