I've researched and researched this same question- myself and 9 friends and family are all getting the red 1/4 with everyone getting a box of 12 gold refills- they are the acid free ones. We are going with
www.cropandstick.com they had awesome prices and great customer service- if you go with them - put SplitCoastStamper in the memo- i think the head lady/owner is a member-