Where are you in Indiana? In the Indianapolis-ish area there's The Neu Scrapbooking Store (
https://www.neuscrapbookingstore.com/) in the Beech Grove area, The Glitterie (
The Glitterie | Hobby Store | Greenwood, IN) in Greenwood, and Just a Little Bit Moore (
Scrapbooking Store in Mooresville, IN | Scrapbook Classes) in Mooresville. About an hour south of Indianapolis in Nashville is Wishful Thinking (
Welcome to Wishful Thinking!) and Papertrix (
Home Page). In northwest IN, there's Cafe Crop (
Cafe Crop :: Home) in Merrillville. In southwest IN, there's The Doodlebug (
The Doodlebug, Inc - Home) in Jasper. Due north of Indianapolis is Stamp-N-Toys (
http://www.stamp-n-toys.com/) in North Webster. The only store I haven't been to is Stamp-N-Toys. All of the others are really nice stores and have a good selection.
You can also look at the websites for Stampin' Up! (
Stampin' Up! - Rubber Stamps, Ink, Paper, Tools, and Accessories), Close to My Heart (
http://www.closetomyheart.com/default.aspx), and Fun Stamper's Journey (
Craft Stamps & Paper Crafting by Fun Stampers Journey) to see if the there is a demonstrator near you.
Welcome back and good luck!