They weren't going to be wedding-themed. The first gift idea I had was to carve a candle at work, but I have no idea if either of them would like that. The card design I was thinking about uses Simple Sketches, and I was going to make a congratulations card that sort of went along with them using the couple stamp from Summer by the Sea. Don't worry, I will be sure to post both to my gallery when I'm done!
I'm not sure how many details were carefully planned, and have actually never met his fiancee. The whole thing was pretty quick -- they met less than a year ago, and were engaged earlier this year!
Thanks for the suggestions, everyone! I will make as many as I am able to between now and Monday night, and we'll see what I end up with! My boyfriend wasn't really able to spend money on a gift, either, so he offered TJ a free place to stay as he traveled between Philly and Annapolis to plan the wedding!