Simply Adorned charms--stay closed?

[BrennaLynn]

Hi y'all,

Do any of you have any experience with the Simply Adorned charms from Stampin' Up!? Do they stay closed if you bump your charm bracelet up against a counter, for instance? I want to figure this out before I buy a bunch to make presents with.

TIA!
Brenna in TX

[catherinep]

Hi Brenna! I don't know if anyone else has had a different experience, but a friend of mine AND myself have had the inserts we made for the bracelets fall out. Just my honest experience.
The necklaces, never! Those puppies stay closed tight!