It's so funny - I was just thinking about this today.
I'm pretty much over the pretty paper problem because I have learned that there will always be something else that I like just as much. Although I've thought about making a little swatch book with my favorites though - as inspiration for color combinations, and let's face it, so I'll always have a piece of it.
Like Szesa, I have this issue with other consumables. As soon as I find something I absolutely love, I start to think about running out of it.
I've been wanting to try Memento Luxe ink pads. Late Tuesday night, I found an online store that is in my own state and they had a good price on them so I placed an order. They arrived early this afternoon in today's mail and I tried them immediately. What a nice ink pad! But. . . I almost immediately started to wonder, if I love them and use them a lot, just how long will it be before they become dry? Crazy talk, I tell you. I have many ink pads that seem to last forever so it's a bit illogical.
By the way, the store is:
stampingscrapping.com