I've only been to Maui and the Big Island. From my experience, I would vote the Big Island for more to see, quieter, and more snorkeling and turtle opportunities. Maui (Lahaina) was more romantic and better for whale watching.
I'm Heidi, and I'm a stamping addict; Blog
DT Member of The Friday Mashup & MDS Monday Challenges
Friends don't let friends stamp alone! Hudson Valley SBS 3/14/15