Kristen, I hear you! Some days I look at all my creative clutter and I just feel overwhelmed by it all. Then I think of all those hard earned dollars I have spent on the stuff and I find it hard to let it go, promising myself I WILL use them. I have to get real with myself about all that stuff.
I think your list is perfect as it really lends itself to being able to do something specific in January toward meeting several of those goals. I find that to be the biggest motivator for me, when I see myself actually making progress on a goal.
A suggestion for your "make more cards..." goal. Maybe select different destination each quarter. You get to do something nice for multiple causes and you might find that, in the process, you find THE one that most speaks to your heart.