What a fun thread! Here are my lists.
Hot air balloons & clouds
Buttons & twine
Big Shot/Nesties/dies (especially dies that match stamp sets)
All things made by PTI
Most things made by Flourishes
Not feeling the love at all:
Weird people with huge heads, tiny bodies, missing features
Weird altered vintage images of people with dunce caps, party hats, crowns, wings, wands
Images that look like preschoolers drew them
Goofy, sappy sentiments
Gaudy or clashing color schemes
Huge prima flowers (small ones are fine)
Crooked focal points
I love sparkle!