My best sellers are:
Ornaments- I make some using the acetate and some with re-inkers and glitter. Both sold out at $3 each.
Snowman soup- I started out making them from the mug template, but found some mugs at Hobby Lobby for $.77 and stamped snowflakes on Night Of Navy cardstock using the White Craft Pad. Filled the mug with all the goodies and printed the poem on a tag with a stamped snowman image on the other side- Sold these for $5 each.
Candles- I made some stamping on the tissue paper and some I downloaded images of Victorian Santa's and Angels and printed them directly on tissue paper. Then I put wax paper over the images and heat set. These went like CRAZY! Sold them for $5 for small short candles and $8 for the taller candles.
2x2 tile magnets- I stamped snowman, Christmas images, used the All Gods Children set, Polar Bears set, etc. I sell them for $1 each.